This is a partner-pair speaking activity for English beginners that is primarily focused on providing repeated phonics encoding/decoding practice within the context of a fun activity.
The two partners in each partner-pair work together, taking turns being the Participant 1 and Participant 2. For each round, Participant 1 begins by drawing 1 card from the Secret Card Deck.
Then, Participant 2 asks questions (using the provided Core Vocabulary Words and Sentences / Sentence Patterns) and systematically crosses off possibilities on a Deduction Panel until only one option remains.
Minimum Prerequisites: Students can participate fully in this Deduction Challenge with the Set A Materials after memorizing:
Full Prerequisites: Students can participate fully in this Deduction Challenge with all of the activity’s available materials after memorizing/learning:
Materials Available:
Deduction Challenges are an excellent example of information-gap activities, which serve as communication practice exercises in both Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) and Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT). These challenges provide language learners with repeated practice of important sentence patterns and topic-specific vocabulary.
Additionally, since successful completion of the Deduction Challenge task described below relies on accurately communicating information, the activity offers students an excellent opportunity to self-assess their communication accuracy and initiate error-correction themselves.
This is far more efficient and effective than students only knowing that they are making an error if an instructor points it out. It also empowers learners to seek out solutions to mistakes themselves, rather than primarily being passive receivers of teaching and error-correction.
1. Be able to pronounce and differentiate a variety of single-syllable CVC phonics words with both short and long vowel sounds (for the characters’ names featured heavily in this activity).
2. Gaining basic mastery in using the following sentence pattern and sentence to successfully collect information in English:
“Is _______________ on this membership list?”
“Do you have the membership list for the _______________ club/team?”
3. Gaining basic mastery in using the following phrases to answer questions accurately:
“Yes, he/she is.”
“No, he/she isn’t.”
“Yes, I do.”
“No, I don’t.”
On-Going Self-Assessment:
During each round of play, Participant 2 attempts to determine which list of names on a Deduction Panel matches the membership list on Participant 1’s Secret Card, based only on Participant 1’s answers.
The 2 members of a partner-pair will be able to self-assess their own performance after Participant 2 asks “Do you have the membership list for the _______________ club/team?”
If the answer is “Yes, I do.” then Participant 1 can then show the Secret Card and the 2 partners can double-check if their verbal communication was successful. If they failed to successful communicate, they can figure out which mistake they made and then reattempt the Deduction Challenge with a new Secret Card.
Graduation:
Learners will have achieved the Learning Goals listed above when they can consistently complete the Deduction Challenge correctly with any randomly selected Secret Card, while using the target Sentences / Sentence Patterns and Core Vocabulary Words confidently and without hesitation.
1. Introduce the Core Vocabulary Words and encourage the students to learn them.
2. Demonstrate the Deduction Challenge activity, including correct use of the Core Vocabulary Words and Sentence Patterns.
3. Allow the students to practice the Deduction Challenge repeatedly.
4. The instructor’s role is to monitor the students’ practice to ensure correct use of the activity’s Sentence Patterns.
5. When students fully achieve the activity’s Learning Goals, the instructor can then graduate the student(s) to a new learning opportunity/activity that further builds on the newly achieved learning.
Notes:
If Cheat Sheets are not utilized, students should be required to demonstrate sufficient memorization of the Core Vocabulary Words before they are approved to participate in the Deduction Challenge activity.
For classes with only 1 student, the instructor will also need to be the student’s practice partner.
1: Hobby Club Cards
Each of these cards feature a different list of club/team members. For this partner-pair activity, these cards serve as Secret Cards.
There are 3 different sets of 18 cards, which are labelled Set A, Set B, and Set C.
Each partner-pair participating in this activity will need 1 Secret Card at time, to be held by Participant 1.
One set of these cards is suitable for a group of up to 36 activity participants. If there are more than 36 participants (18 partner-pairs), then additional cards will need to be added to the secret card deck.
•
For each round of this Deduction Challenge, Participant 1 holds onto a single Secret Card and does not show it to Participant 2 until Participant 2 has narrowed down the choices on their Deduction Panel to just one.
2: Hobby Clubs Deduction Panels
The following Deduction Panels are available:
Each partner-pair participating in this activity will need their own Deduction Panel, for use by Participant 2.
Page 2/2 of Set A of the Hobby Club Cards
Page 2/2 of Set B of the Hobby Club Cards
Hobby Clubs Deduction Panel B
The Sentences & Sentence Patterns Used in this activity include everything needed to successfully complete this Deduction Challenge. While sentences can indeed be composed that would allow for the activity to be completed more efficiently, the provided sentences & sentence patterns below are specifically chosen to maximize learners’ use of the activity’s Core Vocabulary Words.
If the answerer was permitted to simply name the hobby/sport shown on their Secret Card, this Deduction Challenge could be completed with a single question and answer. However, by limiting Participant 1’s responses to yes/no answers, Participant 2 must compose more questions than would otherwise be necessary.
Sentences & Sentence Patterns |
Is _______________ on this membership list? |
Yes, he/she is. |
No, he/she isn’t. |
Do you have the membership list for the _______________ club/team? |
Yes, I do. |
No, I don’t. |
The Core Vocabulary Words listed below are all words that students should learn BEFORE attempting the Deduction Challenge described on this page. Students will only need to learn the words listed for a specific set of materials to play to complete the Deduction Challenge with those materials.
For example, to attempt the Deduction Challenge with the Set B materials, the students will only need to know the 21 words listed for Materials Set B.
Core Vocabulary Words To Pre-Learn | |
Materials Set A (18 Cards) | biking, chess, club, coding, cooking, dancing, fishing, guitar, hiking, jogging, list, painting, piano, photography, reading, sports, surfing, swimming |
Materials Set B (18 Cards) | badminton, baseball, basketball, bowling, club, curling, cricket, field hockey, football, golfing, handball, hockey, judo, karate, lacrosse, list, soccer, table tennis (ping pong), team, tennis, volleyball |
Materials Set C (18 Cards) | bird watching club, board games club, book club, brass band, carpentry club, film club, French, history club, Japanese club, kites club, list, map making club, math competition/olympiad team, orchestra band, rock band, singing club, Spanish club, strings band |
Notes:
*There is also the option to provide learners with a Cheat Sheet listing all of the Core Vocabulary Words next to their images. This will allow them practice using all of the vocabulary words without needing to first memorize them. The process of learning the words can be scaffolded by first allowing students to use the Cheat Sheet, and then (once they have some familiarity) encouraging them to flip the Cheat Sheet face-down and only use it after first attempting to recall a needed vocabulary word from memory.
The following words will be used to the play this game (with every available set of cards). However, these words don’t need to be pre-taught. These words can and should be learned WHILE playing the game. The instructor’s demonstration of how to play the game will provide an opportunity to show how all of these words are used as part of useful communication sentences.
Vocabulary Best Learned in Context | |
Used With All Material Sets | do, don’t, for, have, he, I, is, isn’t, membership, no, on, she, the, this, yes, you |
Most of the words included on this list are hard (or virtually impossible) to depict visually on a flashcard. Demonstrating them while introducing this Deduction Challenge and then having learners use them while participating in the activity is an optimal strategy for helping learners understand the words’ meaning (based on context/function).
This Set A card shows the membership list for the chess club.
This Set B card shows the membership list for the field hockey team.
This Set C card shows the membership list for the map making club.